From Moratorium to Compact: Gary’s Opportunity to Shape the AI Economy

As technology companies pour billions into artificial intelligence infrastructure, Gary’s data center moratorium offers an opportunity to rethink how cities participate in the economic value of industrial development.

Share
Aerial view of downtown Gary, Indiana, showing civic buildings, highways, rail corridors, industrial facilities, and Lake Michigan.
Gary, Indiana's civic and industrial landscape reflects the city's longstanding role in the American economy. Its data center moratorium creates an opportunity to shape the next wave of infrastructure investment. (City of Gary)

Gary, Indiana, has given itself something increasingly valuable in the race to build America’s artificial intelligence infrastructure: time to negotiate.

In September, Mayor Eddie Melton signed an executive order imposing a one-year moratorium on new data center development. With no facilities currently operating within city limits, local officials have a window to examine how AI infrastructure could fit into the city's economic future, from electricity and water requirements to employment, tax revenues, and long-term community benefits.

The decision comes as technology companies invest billions in computing capacity, power systems, and industrial-scale facilities across the United States, reshaping electricity demand, industrial land markets, and regional economic development strategies. Cities with available land, existing industrial infrastructure, and access to energy networks are becoming increasingly relevant to an industry that depends on physical assets as much as software.

Gary has many of the characteristics that could make it attractive in this new investment cycle. Its industrial history also provides a useful perspective on how the city might approach this opportunity differently.

An industrial city meets a different industrial economy

Gary was built around one of the twentieth century's most consequential industrial investments. Steel production generated employment, supported local businesses, and helped the city's population reach more than 178,000 in 1960. By 2020, that population had fallen to 69,093, reflecting decades of industrial restructuring, job losses, and demographic change.

The economic model emerging around artificial intelligence is fundamentally different. Data centers can require billions of dollars in capital while employing relatively few permanent workers. Their primary outputs are computing capacity and digital services, often sold to customers far beyond the communities where the facilities operate.

This distinction has important implications for local economic development. Traditional industrial recruitment often measures success through capital investment, employment commitments, and anticipated tax revenues. These indicators remain relevant, but they capture only part of the economic contribution of infrastructure-intensive industries.

A data center may increase a city's assessed property value and construction activity without creating an equivalent expansion in permanent local employment. Its electricity requirements may also necessitate infrastructure investments whose costs and benefits extend across an entire utility service territory.

For Gary, the opportunity is to translate the next wave of industrial investment into stronger local businesses, greater economic participation, and community assets whose value remains connected to the city over time.

The scale of potential infrastructure investment adds another dimension. NIPSCO's 2024 Integrated Resource Plan projects approximately 2,600 megawatts of additional electricity demand from major economic development projects by 2035, including data centers and other industrial customers. While the timing and scale of that demand remain uncertain, accommodating it could require substantial investment in the region's electricity infrastructure.

How those investments are financed, who bears the costs, and how much value remains in the local economy will shape the region's economic development decisions in the years ahead.

The capital behind AI is facing greater scrutiny

The financial scale of the AI infrastructure expansion became clearer on October 28, when Alphabet, Google's parent company, released its third-quarter results.

The company reported $127.6 billion in quarterly revenue, up 25% from a year earlier. Google Cloud revenue more than doubled to $30.7 billion, reflecting strong demand for AI infrastructure and services. Capital expenditure reached approximately $51.4 billion during the quarter, while free cash flow was negative $9.1 billion, reflecting heavy infrastructure spending and other cash outflows.

The figures illustrate both the extraordinary pace of AI investment and the financial pressures accompanying it. As technology companies commit increasingly large sums to infrastructure, investors are paying closer attention to financing requirements and the returns those investments are expected to generate.

Similar scrutiny should extend to the financial implications for cities and utilities hosting these investments. A technology company's announced capital expenditure does not necessarily match the economic value the host community captures. Nor does a private investment commitment necessarily cover every infrastructure cost required to support a project.

The distinction becomes important when electricity networks, water systems, and other infrastructure must accommodate new demand. These assets may remain in place for decades, even as technology, business models, and demand projections change. Understanding who finances them, who bears the risks, and who benefits from their use is essential to evaluating the full economic impact of development.

As investors assess whether AI infrastructure will deliver adequate returns on capital, cities can apply comparable discipline to their economic development decisions. Success should be measured not only by the amount invested, but by how the resulting costs, risks, and returns are distributed.

Indiana is already beginning to address these questions. In October, state regulators approved an AES Indiana agreement under which Google will cover its electricity costs and the new infrastructure required for its proposed data center in Morgan County. The arrangement includes financial safeguards for existing customers, demonstrating how infrastructure costs can be allocated to the industrial customers driving new demand.

But protecting ratepayers is only one part of the development equation. How communities share in the economic value these investments create is another.

From community benefits to community participation

Negotiations over major development projects often center on community benefits agreements, which may include commitments to local employment, procurement, infrastructure improvements, environmental protections, and neighborhood investment.

These arrangements can create meaningful value, especially when commitments are enforceable and outcomes are publicly reported. But the capital-intensive nature of AI infrastructure presents an opportunity to think more broadly about how communities participate in the industries they host.

What would it mean for a community to participate not only in the benefits of development, but also in the economic activity and assets that support it?

The infrastructure surrounding data centers offers one possibility. Electricity generation, battery storage, construction, maintenance, and specialized technical services create commercial opportunities beyond the facilities themselves. Depending on project economics and regulatory requirements, local businesses, investors, and community institutions may participate in these supply chains or invest in supporting assets.

Financial arrangements offer another avenue. Rather than relying exclusively on one-time contributions, communities could negotiate mechanisms that channel development-related revenues or benefits into revolving investment funds, local enterprises, or revenue-generating assets. Participation in energy projects could offer additional opportunities where commercially viable and consistent with utility regulation.

These structures require careful financial and legal analysis. Ownership brings risks and potential returns, and public institutions or community investors would need the expertise and safeguards to assess commercial viability and manage their exposure.

The underlying principle is that economic development can extend beyond employment and taxation to include the creation and ownership of productive assets. In Gary, that distinction could help determine whether AI infrastructure becomes another source of economic activity or a foundation for broader local wealth creation.

What a community data center compact could accomplish

Gary's moratorium provides an opportunity to translate these principles into a more coherent development framework.

A community data center compact could establish shared expectations among local government, utilities, developers, investors, and community institutions before individual projects advance through the approval process. Such a framework could organize those expectations around three objectives.

First, infrastructure protection would establish transparent requirements for electricity and water demand, cost allocation, environmental performance, resilience, and long-term liabilities. These commitments would matter in a city where household energy affordability and infrastructure reliability are already significant concerns.

Second, economic participation would identify opportunities for residents, businesses, and educational institutions through local contracting, workforce development, technical services, and supplier relationships. Commitments could be tied to measurable outcomes rather than projected economic impacts alone.

Third, local value retention would examine opportunities for long-term asset creation and financial participation, including investment in supporting infrastructure, community investment mechanisms, and commercially viable ownership structures.

A compact would not replace existing utility regulation, environmental review, zoning requirements, or development agreements. Instead, it would connect these processes to a broader assessment of local economic value, with clear expectations, measurable commitments, and accountability for results.

The value of the year ahead

Gary's one-year moratorium offers an opportunity to establish the foundations for a more deliberate approach to industrial development. During this period, the city can assess its infrastructure capacity, identify opportunities in the data center supply chain, and examine how different investment structures could affect local businesses, residents, and public finances.

The more consequential task is defining what long-term success should look like. A decade from now, Gary should measure AI infrastructure's contribution by more than the number of facilities built or the total capital invested. More meaningful indicators would include improved infrastructure reliability, growth among local businesses, access to higher-value economic opportunities, and the creation of assets and revenue streams that continue generating value within the city.

The moratorium's success will be measured by whether it produces a framework that can guide future investment decisions, establish enforceable commitments, and track outcomes over time.

For a city that has experienced both the prosperity and the consequences of industrial transformation, the stakes extend well beyond another large facility. Gary can help demonstrate how the next generation of American infrastructure can strengthen not only the companies that own it, but also the cities that make it possible.